Skip to content

My "new" M&H AA

RIP

Reposting:

I am not sure how I overcame the financial, logistical and marital hurdles that were separating my daughter and myself from this piano, but apparently I did.

The piano is either 1928 or 1930: the second owner of the instrument (who died 20 years ago) left the paperwork of his purchase which say it was manufactured in 1928, but serial number points at 1930. Probably shortly before his death the owner had the plate regilded, and had installed new strings, new tuning pins, new damper felts. Soundboard and bridges appear to have gotten some attention too. There is no record of these works, but according to my visual inspection and the opinion of the technician I hired, the piano obviously has received very little use since.

The instrument looks nice, and it sounds incredible. I'm still pinching myself because I can't believe this isn't a dream. My daughter glued herself to it...






RIP

Reposting this too, which I think can be very useful to people who want to get a better instrument than they currently have, are not in a hurry, and have "obstacles" (financial, marital, logistics etc) to overcome, with practical suggestions on how to make your own dream come true as I did for mine.

Background: when I saw posts similar to the one I started this conversation with, I congratulated the individuals and was sincerely happy for them, but I always thought: "how could you make it work? will I be able to, with 4 mouths to feed, bills and mortgage to pay, money to save for kid's college, all out of a single salary?" -- answer: be really frugal, save as much as possible, work a little more (things that I needed to do just to pay my mortgage and feed my single bachelor mouth when two decades ago I was living in Europe -- as a US citizen now I'm fortunate that I need to do these things only to get "disposable" income for my hobby, rather than survive as I did back then)

Let's go into the specifics: I got a management course at work, to teach me how to make people do what the supervisor wanted. No, it's not how to become a headshrinker and manipulate others, quite the contrary! It's about you understanding them, learning what they REALLY care about, and finding common points between them and you (well in the case of marital issues, being married, there obviously are already plenty of common points, or why did we marry in the first place?) -- and actually YOU doing what THEY want. As I said, the exact contrary of what you'd think.  Let me share 30% of the work which achieves 70% of the result.

  1. have frequent conversation (which I was having with my wife regardless)
  2. really listen what the other party say, ESPECIALLY in between the lines, perhaps not explicitly
  3. do the real deal game https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B08BW1GP66/ and use it to understand the other party

Once you do this really well, you understand people and become best friends with anybody you want. In the case of your spouse, you actually did these things naturally "back then", but then forgot about it. Being more intentional now, you may "fall in love again".

So long story short, I got the priorities of my wife much better, and satisfied them before mine, among others regarding travel and her need to "fix" (paint and upgrade furniture) in our living room.

Back to pianos, I monitored the local market for instruments of my interest for a few years, bought and sold a few (in total I owned 6). Given my very limited budget, I needed to buy and sell without too much of a loss, while having an instrument to play, and slowing "climbing" to better ones. As such I monitored instruments I intended to sell too. So I learned when, in my market, the instruments sell well (August-October), when they sell worse (April-June), what the sellers and buyers valued most (time and convenience above money) and many other details, including the fair, lowest and highest price of the instruments in question. A couple of times I bought a new one in April and sold the old one in October, which was financially good, but not so for my wife ("oh no! too many pianos in the living room! What a mess!") -- It's also very good for us Americans, that there is plenty supply of 70-100 year old instruments which were never built in Europe, or were destroyed by either of the world wars. Many are junk, but plenty are ok, and some are pretty good.

Moreover, I made contact with technicians in the area where I could travel in a day asking if they knew of someone who was looking for the instrument like mine or who was selling the one I was looking for.

When I put my small grand on sale, knowing it was not the best time, I asked a fair price, and made it super convenient for the seller: you just tell me your address, and the piano will appear there, white-glove-services (see below). In other markets, price might be more important than time/convenience.

Lots of patience, many lost opportunities, each one with a story longer than this message and a lesson learned. Some friends made (partly thanks to 1-2 above). Eventually this M&H went on sale, and I was ready with one of my contacts (a technician) to inspect it immediately. I went to see it a couple of days after he gave me his go ahead (I'd have gone first, but it was a 3h one-way drive). I bought it on the spot. I already knew everything I needed for movers, storage (more on this in a moment) and all the logistics in place, so I had no hesitation (lesson learned from a past lost opportunity)

I turned the conversation with my wife from "oh no, you bought yet another piano? now we'll have two instruments in the living room again?" into "I bought a new piano and it's in storage, I sold the old one and it will be gone on day X -- let's get rid of old stuff and take the time to renovate the room to your liking". A bit more money to spend, but not outrageously so (thanks COVID stimulus). I stayed without any (acoustic) pianos for a while, painted the room, assembled new bookshelves, moved other furniture... had a nice time with my wife making our "nest" as when we were young and preparing to go living together.... this time with the kids helping. And now I have a new piano, new living (aka music) room (well, still some work to be completed...) and we are all happy.

Hope this message will inspire you about what you can do to change your dream instrument, if you are not satisfied with your current one. You can do it too.

PS: actually things went different compared to my plan: if we spoke in late April, I'd have told you that as soon as the baby grand sold, I'd have bought https://www.insidepianos.com/baldwin-details (with the hassle and expense of travelling there to try it, and the additional transportation issues)... but I was ready for alternatives....


RIP

And finally reposting this other one also:

The whole instrument has an almost "perfect" sound: dark timbre, awesome to my liking; nice tone; very responsive to dynamics without being skittish: a bit forgiving to small imprecisions and with apparent infinite ability to go softer and especially louder and louder. If I had to find a hammer-related "defect", it's that I could appreciate a bit more of "bloom". I know that with proper voicing I could get that, and one day I might go there, but for now I am enjoying and getting to know fully what I have, which is fantastic!! You can hear the sound of this piano at

https://vimeo.com/channels/donotshootthepianist/

It was recorded with a low tier Android phone, so the quality leaves something to be desired (among other things the dynamics is very compressed, with fff and ppp sounding almost the same smirk ) , but the timbre is decently clear when using headphones. I have changed the compression scheme to keep the original audio and compress only the video, so the metallic "sh" at each note attack (an artifact of the compression which I mentioned in another forum) is not present. That does not change the phone's microphone into a professional one, but with my SHP9500 I am satisfied on how similar it sounds compared to hearing it live!

It goes without saying that I am satisfied with my performance (it's just a first shot without much rehearsing), not to mention the background noises from the birds and the steps of the kids and... well, at least I've been able to dodge the sound of the hailstorm. One of these days I should record something better….


TomLC

RIP Congratulations! Beautiful!


Deleted

RIP It was recorded with a low tier Android phone, so the quality leaves something to be desired

It's a real recording for once. The quality is already better than anything I ever heard from Pianoteq.

RIP not to mention the background noises from the birds and the steps of the kids and... well, at least I've been able to dodge the sound of the hailstorm

That's an inseparable part of music-making in the home. Embrace it!



CyberGene

Sounds really nice! Do you tune it yourself?


magicpiano

That's a nice baby grand. I'm happy for you!

It sounds very nice but there is the A4 note that needs some tuning. 😉


RIP

Thanks everybody 😀

@dore_m yes, making a recording of this instrument for you to create a free library is on my todo list. I was hoping to outsource it to my daughter but that did not work (yet?)

FWIW, the only way that she could "separate" from the grand we had before is by recording it in the hope to get a free library for that too -- I think I pinged you about that on PW at a moment you were too busy, so we did not get the feedback about how good or how bad those recordings were (not that it really was such a nice instrument worth sharing with others in a library, but anyway…) -- I also thought that my daughter would have asked me repeatedly about it, but instead the M&H blew her socks off and she forgot about what we had before 😆

@dore_m what would be the best way to do it incrementally? Record just a couple of octaves? Or just one velocity layer but whole? Doing the whole instrument the other time was a time sink which is hard to replicate, especially in a sound-clean environment (dishwasher, birds chipping, forced air heating, squirrels running on the roof, other outside noises…) -- in any case I'm waiting a couple of more weeks of "full heating" to get it tuned after it adjusts to the seasons change. Actually, now that I think about it, please reply to these questions in a separate thread rather than here.