David Lai struggling to remember recordings I heard where the piano was spotless and without random noises or resonances
Indeed.
One of my all-time favorite CDs is "Soul of the Bass" by John Patitucci.
The majority of the tracks (solo double bass) on that album are recorded as dryly and closely as it gets.
You hear the wood of the bass creaking and sighing, everything that is going on with the strings, and even hear John literally breathing the music.
To me, this is music at its finest, so complete, honest, and authentic.
I love it ♥️ 🎶.
HZ