Pianissimo
Pianissimo Seriously confused with the statement that he is overrated. I’ve actually never heard anyone say that.
Hancock is definitely not overrated when it comes to his rightful place in jazz history. He has written, compositions that are now considered to be jazz standards, his early work with Miles Davis helped to redefine the role of the piano in a jazz rhythm section, he pushed the boundaries of harmonic concepts and “jazz” vocabulary and then went on to expand the definition of what “jazz” could be with Mwandishi and with the Headhunters. His Headhunter era remains a huge influence on many young players over multiple genres.
Maybe you’re saying you don’t find his technique is that impressive and you would like to hear more of a classical and “ECM” influence ala Jarrett? His stature and place in jazz history is undeniable and you would be hard pressed to find any jazz historians, serious jazz fans or top jazz pianists who would state Hancock’s career and overall influence on pushing the music forward to be “overrated”.
I’m not trying to change your opinion on his playing as the music we enjoy helps to define our own style and voice on the instrument, just adding a little context as to why Hancock is held in such high regard.
